An action-packed slog

The film may be flawed, but its message is not.

One of those movie experiences that is so good it makes you realize you've been grading everything else on a curve.

An old-fashioned movie made with new-fashioned finesse.

Maggie Cheung is impressive in this film, which showcases her as a serious actor and woman of the world, as she seamlessly speaks English, French, and Cantonese (and even sings). Nick Nolte turns in a fine performance as well. Unfortunately, I found the script to this story of redemption from drugs not as strong as their acting, often wandering, and Olivier Assayas's direction to plod along. I confess that addiction movies are harder for me to enjoy to begin with. The musical performances and soundtrack for such a film could have been better showcased, which, while I suppose wasn't the point of the movie, would have made it more entertaining. I did like the cinematography and panoramic shots that Eric Gautier gave us, but wouldn't recommend this movie without reservations.

This movie is badly written and well acted, which is a shame because you're interested in the characters right away, and the movie begins as though it's going to be a different sort of drug redemption film, one that might just skate the line between glorification and demonization. Instead, the script loses it's emotional way and falls fast into a four star disappointment. Terrible follow-through. Both maggie cheung and nick nolte provide a fair- enough effort, yet their relationship never picks up any developmental speed. The other characters are quasi-interesting, but probably because we never really find out anything about them. Plus, the little boy didn't get the direction he needed, because he sounds like he's reading lines, to the point that you're embarrassed for the filmmakers that they even attempted the hook, line and cute-kid sinker. And finally, the music should be more than just set dressing in a story so critically dependent on rock credibility. Though i'd admit that there were a couple interesting sequences, i wouldn't recommend a film this weak to anyone. The script doesn't nearly get redeemed by any particular virtue of filmmaking.

How many cigarettes do characters need to smoke on screen before one is tempted to suggest this film cripples itself in a endless, looping tribute to French cinema circa 1965 a la Jean-Luc Goddard? That M. Cheung won best actress for this at Cannes is absolutely baffling, suggesting again that there is much more than meets the eye to jury selection and awards at festivals. Cheung's character travels a flat-line arch; there is no development. No explanation is provided for her character's 'getting clean' other than forced detox in prison, buffered by methadone and then, brace yourself, so she can be trusted to see her son (whom she basically abandoned years ago). Drug use, abuse and addiction can offer some opportunities for storytelling. How one gets there, how one stays there and how one gets out (if at all, see 'Leaving Las Vegas'). Not much of an attempt is made to find out why Cheung's character is/was such a loser, the mother-son bond appearing only as a bald attempt to create character motivation. Clearly in love with itself, this film stood me up. I'm sorry it wasn't better.

I think the movie has been made with a good intention, however it is far from reality. The reason why i am stating so boldly is, i myself counsel at a halfway house, interact with them and constantly try to figure out what works for them to overcome. The role played by Maggie was Worthy watching, what i meant by commenting 'far from reality' is the movie shows a high profile couple addicted to heroin. Maggie's decision to give up drugs to get back her son Jay was clearly not portrayed well. If giving up drugs was so easy, i don't think anybody would like to be hooked on to it. A strong motivation surely helps, however cannot be the only factor for somebody to recover from addiction. The movie shows as though all her friends are concerned with her addiction and want her to get back to normal life, in real life, co-addicts are the greatest friends of addicts. A similar hangout place or a simple stress can trigger an addict to relapse, Maggie seems to miraculously win over everything in no time.