Good films always raise compelling questions, whether the format is fiction or documentary fact.

If you're interested in the topic at hand, you should just watch it and judge yourself because the reviews have gone very biased by people that didn't even watch it and just hate (or love) the creator. I liked it, it was well written, narrated, and directed and it was about a topic that interests me.

Through painfully honest and emotional moments, the movie becomes irresistibly relatable

Through painfully honest and emotional moments, the movie becomes irresistibly relatable

This is not a drama but a documentary slice of life from the latter years of ordinary people who are celebrating together their survival of one the worst tragedies in history.What kind of photography did you expect - avant-garde, intended for the Cannes Film Festival? Gimme a break!The testimonials are incidental to the intent of the film. They are part of it but not the main reason for it.What kind of scholarly thought are you referring to? This shows a total lack of understanding of the movie. It was NOT made as a contribution to the already sizable archive of survivors' testimonials. It wanted to present a an event in the lives of these people that had been re-enacted for a few decades. Why does a documentary filmmaker choose any individual or group of people? Because he/she believes they will make for an interesting story that hasn't been told before or wants to make it in his/her own way. Who should he have chosen in your view? There are hardly any survivors left.The movie wasn't intended to be a revelation of any kind. Everything you said is mean-spirited and makes one wonder whether you had ulterior motives in panning it.No, this documentary is not a tour de force work of art, but it is not anything that you're claiming it is either. Seems to me you're a frustrated amateur film critic that doesn't even have a good command of English. I truly doubt that you have any Holocaust survivor relatives.

Anyone who sees this movie, MUST see "A Film Unfinished." Without a doubt for those that cannot comprehend what these people went through, this film will explain it all. My in-laws were victims of the Holocaust and my Mother in-law who came from Warsaw but was kidnapped by Russians never actually knew what happened to her family. Watch and process "A Film Unfinished" and you will be educated as to what happened to those who were in the Warsaw Ghetto. Some were gassed, some were apart of the Sondokomnados. This group of survivors went through hell and this excellent film displays a spirit you won't see in many places.I was taken with the camaraderie and sincere caring for one another. The fact they were able to connect and make a family amongst a group who had lost all members of their respective families and laugh and smile and have fun is part of the fun of this incredible group of people

Every summer for the past few decades, a group of Jewish Holocaust survivors has met at the Four Seasons Lodge in the Catskill Mountains, drawn together by their unwitting participation in the single greatest crime-against-humanity of the modern era.Though these individuals spend some of their time on camera detailing their harrowing experiences in the death camps, much of the documentary "Four Seasons Lodge," directed by Andrew Jacobs, a writer for "The New York Times," actually focuses on the here and now, on their lives and relationships with one another in the present day.In fact, in many ways, the movie is less about being a concentration camp survivor than it is about the tragedy and trauma of growing old, of having to say goodbye - to each other, to life, and to the lodge itself, whose fate lies in the hands of this ever-diminishing group of people who are now seriously contemplating selling off their shares in it.Perhaps the most poignant moment in the movie is the one in which we see, in grainy home movie footage from several decades back, the much younger versions of these same people, all hearty and hale and in the prime of their lives, dancing up a storm and enjoying to the full their time together. It's a stunning contrast to their condition today.And, yet, through it all, these brave and spirited survivors - who have experienced and endured far more in their lives than the rest of us could possibly even imagine - have somehow managed to persevere and to make something of their lives."Four Seasons Lodge" is no great shakes as a piece of filmmaking. It doesn't tug at the heartstrings or provide grand moments of dramatic revelation as one might expect given the emotional intensity of the subject matter. In fact, the tone of the film is almost defiantly prosaic - a means, perhaps, of showing us just how successfully these people have managed to move on with their lives despite the horrors of the past. Whatever the goal, the movie provides a time capsule for future generations to study over and ponder. And to see history written in these lined, wizened faces.

Unfortunately a promising topic was turned into a sentimental and overwrought drama. Mundane and predictable photography. There is little originality in this documentary as anyone familiar with Holocaust testimonies, and of course the people, has heard these stories with more insight. A superficial and kitschy film which does not add to scholarly thought. One also wonders why the crew chose this particular group; it's never made clear. It looks as if the people have been arranged for shots; definitely a high-budget production with aerials. Doesn't seem to suit the setting. The camera seems obvious, intruding into the lives of these people. Of course this would be unavoidable with a large crew. One wonders how the survivors felt, and that's another problem with the movie. The characters have little depth; they seem to spout expected lines and the whole effect is of a scripted film in which the director has just discovered the Holocaust and thinks he's the first. I watched this with some survivor relatives and they could not relate at all. They knew the clichés and shook their heads hearing them once again, this time portrayed as revelation.