Perfect cast and a good story

Pretty good movie overall. First half was nothing special but it got better as it went along.

Fun premise, good actors, bad writing. This film seemed to have potential at the beginning but it quickly devolves into a trite action film. Ultimately it's very boring.

Amazing worth wacthing. So good. Biased but well made with many good points.

Every time I read news about Hollywood planing to make a Metal Gear Solid movie,I feel scared about how the new Hollywood would massacre the video game series.Giacomo Talamini has done exactly what the MGS saga deserves, a live action movie made from the love to the story and the characters and not from the love to the money, that is exactly what Hollywood makes these days,expensive movies without soul. Philantrophy really capture the essence of the video game, the Snake performance by Talamini is perfect,exactly as the snake of the games...the film quality is beyond be amateur, Giacomo shows a big sense of the image on every scene, knowing to chose the right shot on every moment,personally I love the way he uses the shadows enhancing the snake's dark side, this guy really has talent...the film is the first part of a trilogy, I really hope they can finish it..For me, this great film proves one thing, make a good film is not only about money, is about love what you do.The new Hollywood should learn from this guys

Being a big fan of the Metal Gear series of games I have always been watching out for any signs of movies, or fan productions based around the series. Watching Philanthropy brought back all the good memories of MGS: Snake was portrayed really well, and the voice acting was good as well - everything down to his movements were perfect.I was slightly put off when I saw Pierre with the DS, but I suppose it plays to the humorous side of Metal Gear Solid and the quirks. I have to say though I wasn't impressed by the lead female, she seemed to bring the whole thing down - she just felt emotionless and dead, and the voice acting didn't match up to the standard of others.Most of the CGI was very good for a budget production, but again some bits did show a few rough edges - but I don't mean any disrespect, what they have achieved here is excellent and especially as a fan production with a zero budget. I am really looking forward to the next instalments.

weak script, terrible acting, not a single believable moment.regardless that, action is sleep-inductive. By the title line, this movie is supposed to "resemble" (from the intro: based on) the metal gear universe, but it definitely doesn't.I started watching this time ago then I sadly quit after a while, then I decided to give it another try after reading (with disbelief) the positive reviews. Watching it fully didn't changed much my mind however, as the final (and only) action sequence is just plain random and definitely, on screen, non-tactical as anything in MGS-fashion should (...if) be.CG is fake, nothing visually spectacular to miss out anyway and ridiculous moments (balancing the many, "brilliant", dialogue lines) are frequent, like the final fight against the metal gear, which is ultimately tragic.through the story there are some briefing sequences focusing on some kind of vague political intrigue, which is, theoretically OK(by that, I don't necessarily mean viewing some naive windows moviemaker-made blue menu mixed with war footage spam popped out on screen into an internet spam-repertoire slideshow) but as the actual action begins nothing else is revealed or gets evolved, not a single twist until you figure out the story just turned out to be a journey-like ride and any military or politic background references are merely inconsistent. Then, characters are clearly over the edge but regardless the performance dorkiness, there's nothing interesting about to live up with the general (boring) situation.The movie runs so slow you'll beg for something to happen until the final battle which shows some production effort but the several nonsensical sequence(s) and the general randomness makes it weak on contents just as the rest of the movieOne strange thing about this I've noticed, I don't know why, (probably everything is just too messy) this is not even one of those flicks where you're pretty sure about what to expect after you've watched the first 20 minutes (if you are) from the rest of the presentation, so you can consider it as a good, artsy feature, if you feel.budget is a missing key factor here by what I've understood, so I give 3 out of 10 for the effort even something like this would deserve something below 0 on standard parameters.

Metal Gear Solid: Philanthropy is a true cinematic experience. Everything in this fan film is dead-on Metal Gear Solid. Anyone who doesn't see the parallels, or discounts them as too vague or unsubstantiated, do not know the MGS Universe. The cast and crew of Philanthropy show a very unique and "solid" vision of the world they've created, and filled that world with everything the fans of the series have come to know and love. Solid Snake is played close to perfection, giving hard advice and scholarly tips to the rest of his group, while showing deep reflections of his actions as the story progresses. His first line in the film, "That's war.", sums this up perfectly. As for the supporting cast, all of the actors play their parts with ease. Nothing seems contrived or hackneyed in their performances, as they get along very well together. Even when we first meet Snake's contact, Pierre, it's obvious that great care was taken with the subtle nods to the MGS world, as this world class soldier was seen playing a Nintendo DS, an obvious tribute to the original Metal Gear Solid game on the PS system, where players can actually find the game's console in the game. And again in the Gamecube game The Twin Snakes, as players are treated to a Gamecube system inside the game itself. With so many little tributes to the games throughout the film, you get an extremely detailed view of the filmmakers intentions: To Make THE Metal Gear Solid Film! Well, it is achieved. Hollywood needs to take note. This is how you make a film based off of a successful video game franchise: With care, love, attention, and a good script behind it. Hive Division is well on their way to becoming a film group worth taking note of, and worth paying to see!