ridiculous rating

This is a tender, generous movie that likes its characters and presents them as real people, full of flaws and strengths.

All of these films share one commonality, that being a kind of emotional center that humanizes a cast of monsters.

Strong acting helps the film overcome an uncertain premise and create characters that hold our attention absolutely.

"Only Yesterday" was simply outstanding! One of the best pre-code movies ever made. Margaret Sullavan received the chance of a lifetime in this plum role as a simple, trusting young girl who loves a soldier (John Boles) during World War One, becomes pregnant by him during a one night stand, and when he returns he doesn't recognize her (or perhaps more cruelly, pretends he doesn't). In disgrace she is sent to her independent minded aunt in New York City, who gets her a job and helps her get on her feet again and raise her child. Billie Burke is absolutely delicious in the role and Reginald Denny charmingly plays the younger man who is in love with her and devoted to her. A delightful scene with them at the piano together had me grinning from ear to ear and saying "Awww....that's so cute!" How refreshing that Hollywood knew how to charm audiences in those days with extra little scenes like this as comic relief.The rest of the cast is stellar, and boasts MANY fine actors in cameo appearances who were popular in the silent days of cinema. Just see how many you can recognize now in the sound era, milling about in the suspenseful crowd scenes, including Marie Prevost, Jason Robards Sr., Louise Beavers, Joyce Compton, Ruth Clifford, Walter Catlett, Arthur Hoyt, George Hackathorne, King Baggot. Even Irene Dunne in a bit part. This must have been seen as a big production for this studio, to have all these stars in one picture.Special mention also goes to child actor Jimmy Butler who played the young son. What an terrific natural actor he was! After seeing him in this I sought out other films he was in and discovered he was exceptional in those films too. Unfortunately he died as a soldier in Europe in the last year of World War Two, dead way too soon for a young lad.This film has never been put on VHS or DVD. I was reduced to buying a bootleg of it, which I hate to do, but if these video and DVD companies refuse to spend the money to put these pre-code masterpieces out on the market, that is what the old time film fan has to resort to in order to obtain a film they long to see. A shame.I gave this film a 10 out of 10.

Failing to acknowledge the fact that the script is based on Stefan Zweig's "Letter from an unknown woman" notwithstanding, Stahl's "Only yesterday" is a jewel of a film.Beautifully written, directed and acted - it is refreshing to see how real films of the golden age of pre-Hayes Code could be. Absolutely no moral judgment is made of the unwed pregnancy of the character after her one night stand with the man she is fascinated with. Leaving Virginia and her crying mother behind for New York and her suffragette aunt (delightfully played by the talented and often typecast Billie Burke) who basically puts it down as a "biological occurrence", something to be lived through - something that happens. The film is full of little touches of real emotions and actions despite the heavy cinematic conventions of the era.A comparison with Max Ophuls' masterpiece "Letter from an unknown woman" (1948) is too thrilling to resist. In Stahl's more "realistic" version the character played by Margaret Sullavan goes from wide eyed ingénue to become the sophisticated witty Mary Lane - a woman who's been through it and kids herself no longer. Beffiting Ophuls' dark and moody amour foux fable - Liza Berndl (Joan Fontaine) though also going from naive to sophisticate (with some hints of prostitution) never gets over the romantic -almost neurotic- obsession with Stefan Brand (Louis Jourdan - the doomed don Giovanni of "Letter" as opposed to "Yesterday"'s regular Wall Street dilettante played by John Bole). Their reaction to a second chance with the object of their desire is as different as their characters...If you should come across this film in a midnight television screening or at your local cinemateque DO NOT MISS IT. Unfortunately you will not be able to find it in VHS or DVD. Time has been kinder to Ophuls' amazing film - if not quite fair either. Maybe one of these days the guys at the Criterion Collection will see to it...

"Only Yesterday" (Universal, 1933), directed by John M. Stahl, marks the movie debut of stage actress, Margaret Sullavan. Capitalizing on the recent success of the first of three screen adaptations to Edna Ferber's romance drama, "Back Street" (1932), also directed by Stahl, and featuring Irene Dunne and John Boles, "Only Yesterday" improves over its predecessor in mood and drama, holding a viewer's interest even during its 108 minute length. In 1934, Universal and Stahl scored box office gold again with "Imitation of Life" starring Claudette Colbert and Warren William, followed by the 1935 version to "Magnificent Obsession" with Irene Dunne and Robert Taylor. With the exception "Only Yesterday," all the movies mentioned above remain memorable mainly because of its latter remakes, for that "Only Yesterday" not only never got remade, it's hardly ever reissued either television or revival theaters, making this a real curio for classic movie lovers.The story opens during the stock market crash of October 1929, causing many stockholders to go penniless and to blink of suicide. James Stanton Emerson (John Boles) has become one of the victims of the crash. He returns home where his wife, Phyllis (Benita Hume) is hosting a dinner party. Not wanting to tell the guests about the stock market, James locks himself in the other room, takes out his gun, writes a suicide note to Phyllis informing her that he cannot live on. But as he is about to do himself in, he notices a letter addressed to him left on his desk marked "URGENT." After opening and reading the letter, Jim thinks back twelve years ago when he was a young lieutenant who meets Mary Lane (Margaret Sullavan) in a party in Virginia. They dance, leave and disappear into the night. Upon their return, the couple find the party to be over. They bid each other goodnight and plan to see each other again. Later, Jim receives orders to report to France with his troops. Afterwards, Mary learns that she is pregnant, and to avoid a possible scandal, she leaves her family to go live with her Aunt Julia (Billie Burke) in New York City. After giving birth to a son the very day the World War ends, Mary tries to locate Jim to tell him the news, but when their paths cross again, on two different occasions, he fails to recognize her, thus leaving Mary to go it alone and raise the boy herself. After finishing reading the letter, Jim realizes there is something more important than himself to think about.The large cast listed in this photoplay include many familiar faces such as Reginald Denny as Bob; Edna May Oliver (mispelled Edna MAE Oliver in opening and closing credits) as Leona Maynard; Jimmy Butler as Jimmy Jr.; Marie Prevost as Amy; with Louise Beavers, Franklin Pangborn and Berton Churchill. During the course of the story, nostalgic tunes are heard, featuring: "Shine On, Harvest Moon" (sung by Billie Burke); "Remember" (by Irving Berlin, played on piano by Reginald Denny); and "Tip Toe Through the Tulips" (sung by Billie Burke). Although Universal could have easily reunited Irene Dunne and John Boles, stars of "Back Street" into this collaboration, since many supporting players from that film were reunited here, including George Meeker, June Clyde, Walter Catlett, Robert McWade and Jane Darwell, the introduction of the youthful Margaret Sullavan gives this story a whole new different outlook, making this a worthy beginning to a fine actress in a very sensitive performance. Sullavan would star in other Universal dramas, especially the 1941 remake to "Back Street," but she is best remembered for her numerous films produced at MGM, particularly "The Shop Around the Corner" (1940) with James Stewart. While John Boles is usually works well in light musicals and comedies, and often type-cast as a neglected but caring husband or "Mr. Nice Guy" in other films through most of the 1930s, it's sometimes hard to accept him playing a man of the world on furlough who seduces innocent young women and unintentionally forgetting about them, a kind of movie role better suited for the Warren William-type of actor. After seeing this production in a very rare TV showing (WNET, Channel l3, New York City, in 1983), two things come to mind: The youthful Margaret Sullavan's unforgettable performance, the other being the question as to why "Only Yesterday" remains to this day a very obscure film. (***1/2)

***SPOILERS*** *SPOILERS*** ***SPOILERS*** Full bore melodrama!Everything you expect from the genre is here!You will cry a river,feel for the heroine and her little boy,Stahl was the prince of the melodrama during those days.This movie is a long flashback:It's black Thursday,the hive of activity is blighted,people are crazy,it's going all over the place.Posh people are throwing a party in a luxury flat:jewels,furs,champagne and caviar.They're dancing on a vulcano.Pretty soon,all of them will be broke.Among them ,a man who thought he got it made:he married a woman he does not love anymore,and now all what's left to him is suicide.But there's this letter.Then begins a journey through the past.A woman he forgot tells him about her life,after the evening of their love atr first sight,the only evening,only yesterday...Then ,the movie focuses on the heroine(touching Margaret Sullavan).He goes to war,she 's pregnant -it's not a shame anymore nowadays,her optimistic aunt tells her-.THe soldier's return scenes are perhaps the best ones in the whole movie.It seems that they may have influenced M.Kalatozov for "The cranes are flying".The parade on the street,with Sullavan trying to catch her lover's eye,her despair when he does not even recognize her are heart-wrenching.As often in melodrama (check "imitation of life" or "back street"),a woman without a man is nothing at all.So the only way left for her is the business one.And generally she succeeds (such is the case of the heroine of "imitation of life").So,Margaret Sullavan makes her way of life ,and becomes the owner of a very chic shop .We only steal a glance at it,the social elevation interests Stahl only because it will allow her heroine to enter her former lover's wealthy world.Her son,now a student in a military school,is what you call mother's pride.so she meets again the man,now married,but,again,he does not know her.Sullavan throw him a line,by telling him she was overjoyed twice in her lifetime,the second time this very evening."And the first time? " the clueless man whispers..She leaves..SPOILERS BEYOND THAT POINT*SPOILERS BEYOND THAT POINT Now we enter the heart of melodrama.No melodrama without a death,generally caused by a fatal illness.Poor Sullavan is about to die,and pretty damn quick.Harrowing last scene mother/son. Now we've gone full circle.Back in the present.The lover has finished his letter.He has understood his wife does not mean the slightest thing for him.He rushes to Sullavan's house,just to learn she 's dead.Then comes a very very strooooong scene.He meets the boy,they begin to speak,the boy shows his medals,and after a conversation about these foolish things that make a life worthwhile,the man says :"I am your father".End of the movie.Sublime!AND END OF SPOILER.END OF SPOILER.It's a pity that this film should be forgotten.Maybe "magnificent obsession" and" imitation of life" have taken advantage of Douglas Sirk's brilliant remakes.If you love these works,you will love "only yesterday " too.And not only yesterday or today but forever.