Well Deserved Praise

This is How Movies Should Be Made

Purely Joyful Movie!

The performances transcend the film's tropes, grounding it in characters that feel more complete than this subgenre often produces.

One of the most benign films I have seen in a long time is the 1937 film "Thunder in the City." The film talks of England being the first country to come out of the depression. What are they talking about? It's only 1937 and it would take the advent of World War 11 to get us out of that mess.Edward G. Robinson gives a lackluster performance in a film with lackluster writing. Having been booted from his position, he ventures off to England to meet some odd relatives. They both think that each other are wealthy, and perhaps a comedy at this time would have been worthwhile. Instead, they plot some sort of business venture with some new metal. This is as about exciting like a walk in the forest at dusk.In the end, Robinson is regarded as a hero among the stockholders even though he has been out-witted. Any thought of Robinson as a leading man here falls flat, as does the picture.

The story behind this film is more interesting than the film itself. Edward G. Robinson was tiring of the constant gangster films that Warner Brothers was giving him, so off he went to England to make a different kind of film. This was the result. And it shows! Robinson is clearly having a great time in this film...and not a gangster to be seen. Unfortunately, the film was relatively unsuccessful at the box office, so it didn't do much to dissuade WB from plopping him back down into primarily gangster-related films. But if there is one reason to watch this film, it's to see Robinson enjoying himself so much here.As to the plot...well, it had potential. An over-the-top product promoter isn't appreciated by his American bosses, so he quits and goes to England to visit his distant relations...and gets caught up promoting a new metal which will revolutionize life...only to be outfoxed by a British entrepreneur. The script seems a bit shaky, as I often find in old films...but usually those made in the early 1930s. Additionally, I'm generally not a fan of British movies from the earlier days of the cinema...and this is no exception.Most of the cast doesn't mean much to Americans, but you will enjoy seeing Nigel Bruce in his typical buffoonery. And Ralph Richardson (with a rather young receding hairline) is here as the British entrepreneur that does the outfoxing.I doubt this one will find much favor among viewers unless they are die-hard Robinson fans (I'm a fan, but not a die-hard). But, judge for yourself.

Nigel Bruce, Watson to Basil Rathbone's Sherlock Holmes in the 1939 "Hound of the Baskervilles" and of the 1940s Holmes movies, was usually cast as a befuddled and kindly Englishman. The actual second son of a baronet, in this 1937 movie he portrays the English Duke who owns an African mine of useless metal no one knows anything about. Edward G. Robinson plays a brash American who gets involved in promoting the mineral. Ralph Richardson, later knighted by the Queen for theatrical excellence, makes an early film appearance. He later played Dr. Watson on British radio with Sir John Geilgud as Holmes. Arthur Wontner made 5 British Sherlock Holmes movies in the early to mid 1930s. Here he makes small but effective appearances as the English cousin of Robinson's returning American, the father of adult children and the owner of an enormous estate that Robinson gets lost in. This is not an exciting, complex movie, but serves a purpose in filmdom for bringing together Bruce, Richardson and Wonter in one story. I plan on winning some bets with other Sherlockians with this information. P.S. I liked the movie itself, it had all the content of an episode of "Friends".

In the middle of one of his disputes with the Brothers Warner, Edward G. Robinson went over to the United Kingdom to make this feature about a fast talking promoter who essentially inflates the value of some mining stock to get more money for the owner who is being squeezed by a tough minded businessman in the purchasing negotiations. The owners are Nigel Bruce and Constance Collier and the businessman is Ralph Richardson in one of his early screen roles.The role Robinson is playing is one Pat O'Brien probably would have been better suited for, it's the kind of fast talking ballyhoo artist that O'Brien did in his sleep. Bruce and Collier are fine, but Ralph Richardson really gives the best performance with Donald Calthrop as a French chemist who has patented the process to manufacture the 'magnalite' ore from the Bruce/Collier mines, a close second.If anyone can tell me what magnalite is I'd like to know. Robinson promotes it in the way that Rock Hudson promoted Vip in Lover Come Back.Thunder in the City is a great deal cheaper on the production values than anything Robinson was doing at Warner Brothers and unfortunately it shows. Still it's not a bad film and it certainly shows British business practice sure ain't different than American ones.