Strong and Moving!

The performances transcend the film's tropes, grounding it in characters that feel more complete than this subgenre often produces.

The best films of this genre always show a path and provide a takeaway for being a better person.

It is neither dumb nor smart enough to be fun, and spends way too much time with its boring human characters.

The writing is good but could be better. I do hope that by season 2(Hopefully!) there's more focus on the story! :) Miss Sherlock's chemistry with Wato was the best part of the whole season one.

Very interesting and creative adaption - Bringing Sherlock Holmes to life if such a personality lived in our times. The cast really have given life to the characters in a unique way and makes you want to re-watch it many times! The friendship and bond between Sherlock and Watson alternatives are very fun to watch, also at times moving for viewers. Only complaint is that it be more better if the seasons had more episodes and took their own pace.Makes you look forward to next seasons.Definitely recommended for weekend watching!

If you've seen the recent Sherlock series' with Dr Strangely B. Cumberbatch this will feel rather familiar.It's good, not great. The plot complexities you'd expect out of the modern Sherlock is there, but it's more a net than a tapestry unfortunately (and I tend to ignore plot holes lest they spoil my fun).Since I have no other Sherlock in front of me, this will do, for now.

Ok so this comes from a normal guy who loved the fast pace and the way of filming "mind palace" done by RDJ & Benedict Cumberbatch in their adaptation of the character. Lets get started Miss Sherlock is weird , yes not is she.. likable/ funny (by me as spectator) ? i don't know what future episodes hold! but as far as episode 1 goes NO! Is she portrayed as smart? yes but she made some blatant mistakes i am mad she did that (or let some thing happen) I loved Wato-San though but the way she ends up being roommate with sherlock felt forced you can notice the police investigator laughing without any reason in a scene, i wonder if they forgot to do montage! Also the crying was cringeworthy in a scene that i had to fast forward that scene in the end , i expected better from HBO, I expected better from Japan (There is a famous brilliant japanese anime called Detective Conan that is inspired from the work of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle the author of Sherlock Holmes and it disappoints me to watch this)