Overrated

Highly Overrated But Still Good

The biggest problem with this movie is it’s a little better than you think it might be, which somehow makes it worse. As in, it takes itself a bit too seriously, which makes most of the movie feel kind of dull.

Through painfully honest and emotional moments, the movie becomes irresistibly relatable

Bubbly Dorothy McNulty and vibrant Bessie Love are the real reason to watch this film that was the stage origin for all those collegiate musicals. By the time MGM bought "Good News" to the screen it was not only compared badly to other college films around (the stage show had been the instigator) but people thought it was old hat!! What was worse was that originally it had been advertised as containing no fewer than 15 songs but as the studio became worried over the dive in popularity that musicals were taking, many of the already filmed production numbers were canned. The two that were retained were the show's highlights. Bubbly Dorothy McNulty from the Chicago production played flapper collegiate Flo who's "let's make Tate known for the Varsity Drag" - as desks are cleared away for dancing co-eds (Ann Dvorak among them) to take centre stage which includes frenetic Flo with tapping so energetic, shoes start to smoke!! and she is wheeled off at the end, exhausted through so much energy!! Even Harry Earle jumps out of a paper bin!Forget the leading lady - Mary Lawlor was from the original Broadway cast but her role could have been played by any half decent ingénue - she plays Connie, a "four eyes" college swat ridiculed for her dowdy dress sense but within minutes of being assigned to help Tom (Stanley Smith) pass his astronomy (!!!) exam so he can play in the big game, is given a make over by Flo and Tom realises that she is the girl for him. Alas, he has already pledged his love to Pat (Lola Lane who is very cute) who is holding him to his promise of marriage - if he wins the big game!!! As Ukelele Ike sings "I'm Pessimistic".... about how this will all pan out!!Far more interesting is zippy Bessie Love as Babe, the campus vamp - "I'm not hard to get but hard to get away from"!!! She sets her cap at Bobby Randall who for all his years at college has never been called to play and he is getting pretty fed up. Gus Shy was also from the original Broadway cast and probably the oldest looking college kid on film - he was in his mid thirties and didn't look a day over 40!! He reminded me of a youngish Harry Green. but he and Bessie were responsible for "Gee, But I'd Like to Make You Happy", first reprised in a risqué version then sung straight with a cute novelty dance. "Ladies Man" is featured as background music as Bobby sorts through photos of his "would be" romantic conquests and the lovely "The Best Things in Life Are Free" is thrown away as Smith sings one verse and then is cut off. The "Good News" number is filmed as it was on the stage with lots of zippy tapping college cuties led by Flo with front flips and splits then Al "Rubberlegs" Norman comes on for a "you'll have to see it to believe it" eccentric dance!! Lost is the Technicolor "Football" "jazz wedding" finale where all the muddled love affairs are sorted out. And Thomas Jackson who was so memorable as the detective in "Little Caesar" plays the football coach!!Even though at just under 90 minutes it played a bit disjointedly, Variety said "it's too fast, too peppy and too entertaining to flop" and I reckon they were right!!!Highly Recommended.

Unlike the 1947 version of this musical comedy, the two leads here are rather stiff, are not given too terribly much to do, and lack any perceivable chemistry. Top billed Mary Lawlor and Stanley Smith as Connie Lane and Tom Marlowe, respectively, play an unlikely collegiate couple. Tom is the star player on the football team at mythical Tait College. He has to pass a make-up exam in astronomy or he won't be able to play in Saturday's big game. Tom goes to his steady girlfriend, Pat, for help with studying. She says that astronomy is really the field of her friend Connie. Connie is a rather homely looking girl when the audience and Tom first see her, and Tom begrudgingly relents but is not looking forward to their study sessions. Connie's friends do a makeover on her before her first study date with Tom and - voilà - suddenly Tom is in love, even proposing almost from his first encounter. I know this is a musical comedy, but, really! Suppose the girl has annoying bad habits, insanity in her family, or layabout relatives or something. Someone should tell Tom that rushing is good in football, not in life. However, he learns this soon enough. You see, before Tom has had a chance to say anything to Pat about his newfound feelings for Connie, Pat announces their wedding plans. It seems Tom forgot that pesky marriage proposal he made to Pat, but Pat didn't.That's the overriding story that gives us an excuse to see the really entertaining parts of the film which amount to a bunch of mini comedy sketches and musical numbers by the supporting players that I thoroughly enjoyed. Although I have to admit that Cliff Edwards appears to be the world's oldest underclassman, he is so entertaining with a remark here and a song there, in particular the catchy "I'm pessimistic", that I'll forget all of that. Penny Singleton - who isn't even billed in the top ten here - gives the blow-out musical performances of this film with "Varsity Drag" and her rendition of the title song "Good News". Bessie Love may be a musical talent in a musical film, but her contribution here is mainly as comedienne as the spritely mischievous coed Babe. The bad tempered and aptly named Beef thinks he has romantic claims on her but she has eyes for Bobbie, a less talented player on the team, and he has eyes for her. However, Bobbie would like to keep those eyes along with his teeth and nose, and if Beef finds out the chances of him keeping these things seem unlikely as Beef is very jealous of Babe.Do note that the finale of this film is lost, but TCM has inserted publicity stills and title cards indicating what happens in this final scene. Although made in 1930, this film is based on a 1927 hit play, thus it is very much steeped in the Jazz Age, with even a mentioning of raccoon coats in the prologue. If you like early talking films I do recommend this one.

This is not the most awful movie musical MGM made. As a matter of fact, in some respects, it is much better than the Peter Lawford/June Allyson version. But it shows its age terribly and either misuses or abuses some rather fine talent. I agree with others that Penny Singleton steals the film. Her renditions of Good News and Varsity Drag hold the film together. What is so disturbing is the total mishandling of Bessie Love, who could entertain with charm and grace, and Cliff Edwards, whose musical efforts are poorly staged and weakly conceived. The others in the film are best forgotten, not because they are bad actors but because they are so badly directed and completely uninspired that they chew up the scenery and mug incessantly. One wonders about MGM's selection of director, usually a sensible and sensitive choice. Perhaps Thalberg was on vacation.There is little or no camera movement and the one or two good moments in the film, such as the brief and crude animation sequence, are too soon forgotten.But worth sitting through the first half for Penny Singleton's tour de force as a singer/dancer. And once that is finished, you'll be as happy as I that some kind soul lost the final reel.

Watching Penny Singleton in this movie was a revelation, and for those who think of her only as the staid title character of the "Blondie" series should catch this movie if only to see her. She's billed 11th (as Dorothy McNulty) but is the centerpiece of two of the big production numbers involving singing and dancing: "The Varsity Drag" and the title song "Good News." Her immense talent is evident as she does her high kicks, somersaults, cartwheels and splits and delivers the rapid-fire lyrics with uninhibited abandon. She was an absolute joy to behold! In addition, Gus Shy, the Danny Thomas look- talk- and act-alike, provides some good comedy that is complemented by that of Bessie Love and Cliff Edwards, while Lola Lane, Mary Lawlor and Stanley Smith provide the love interest. With 11 or so songs, including the ever-popular "The Best Things in Life Are Free," this movie is definitely worth seeing and compares favorably with the 1947 remake. My one complaint was the lack of closeups, although there was a good full-head closeup of Singleton singing "The Varsity Drag." It was very effective.Before the movie was shown on the Turner Classic Movies (TCM) channel, some titles informed us that the last half of the final reel was filmed in an experimental color process and is now lost. But the ever-resourceful station put together some stills at the end with subtitles to describe the outcome. The movie ran 84 minutes instead of the original 90 minutes.