Absolutely Fantastic

it is the rare 'crazy' movie that actually has something to say.

One of those movie experiences that is so good it makes you realize you've been grading everything else on a curve.

Amazing worth wacthing. So good. Biased but well made with many good points.

I cried from start to end. I hate how good it presented the point. You could say I hate how good it was. If it was was then I would not have invested my heart and soul in it. How good it was? The night after I saw the movie I had a dream that I WAS LIVING the movie and it was pretty goddamn painful I tell you... It's a love-hate situation but in the end it made me feel like I was Hilary Swank so I guess that means the movie did its job. If you have a SO then you will feel this movie to its core, if not... good for you because you can watch it without tissues.

The words that came up for me: Pretentious, contrived, melodramatic. It shows a character who is completely immature and dysfunctional. The budding of the romance shown in a flashback was cringe worthy. There is nothing believable about how the "natives" of Ireland are portrayed. Really, there was nothing about the movie that I can say something positive about, and normally, I can salvage some element or two. Normally, I put watched DVDs out in the open for whomever might be interested, but in this case, I'm going to save everyone the mistake of checking it out. IMDb's star rating is often reflective of my view of films, but this is obviously an exception. The only one in my history of relying on IMDb ratings.

P.S. I Love you is my absolute favorite movie! A beautiful love story with a sweet ending! It starts off a little slow and then right there in the beginning they hit you with a death. And throughout the whole movie they bring you back to love they once shared. They show you her struggles and her happy moments. But the whole time he's basically teaching her to love again. And in the end she's practically re invented herself in to the person her husband always aspired her to be. The movie has beautiful scenery and lovely music to follow it. It makes you cry but also makes you smile. A love story like no other. I would recommend this movie to anyone. It's not just some sappy love story but a beautiful one that has a touch of reality in it. Love stories can have more than a happy ending they can have truth showing people the struggles that can lead you to that ending.

Like an Irish theme pub,full of shillelaghs,four - leaf clover,Guiness and bar staff who insist on making shamrocks on the head of your pint of porter. There is even a man dressed as a leprechaun. Only the Americans could believe that an Ireland like this actually exists. John Ford perpetrated a crime against Irishness with "The Quiet Man" with Sean T'ornton and "God Bless all here" from a brave rebel(or murdering terrorist according to one's point of view) and "P.S.I love you" merely perpetuates the stereotype. Mr G.Butler is the wild Irish Rover in New York who suffers from a fatal brain tumour so swiftly it might almost appear rude. His Coleen is Miss H.Swank in a role Miss J.Roberts must have thanked god she was too old for. Prior to his unfortunate demise he wrote a series of letters to his widow which are delivered throughout the film in some mysterious fashion that is only mysterious if you are under ten years of age in which case let me stop you and warn you that there are one or two rather raunchy scenes your mom and dad might not want you to see. Miss Swank follows these letters to the letter - if you get my drift and ends up in old Oireland having sex with one of her late hubby's best mates.Way to go,eh? It will surprise nobody that this bloke eventually ends up with her(and her mother who is casting covetous looks at his fellow farm worker) so it all ends up happily and predictably. Is it just because I'm a bloke?