What makes it different from others?

I gave it a 7.5 out of 10

While it doesn't offer any answers, it both thrills and makes you think.

It's the kind of movie you'll want to see a second time with someone who hasn't seen it yet, to remember what it was like to watch it for the first time.

I am sorry i cant write much about this movie, as all i saw were the 2 scenes from this one (while switching channels). More than that and i would have to go to a doctor's for pulling a muscle in my stomach for laughing too hardBut all i got from those 2 scenes was, rather watch "She's the Man", its not too great, but decent funny movie, and don't waste your time or money on this useless movie.If someone wants me to believe that a FAT Rani mukherjee, at 5'2" with no upper body strength, and without wearing any protective gear can hit a quick bowler (or even show seamer) who plays for a local club team, for six sixes in an over, is not just insulting my cricketing knowledge, but my common sense as well.And who is the target audience for this movie? All i can think of is Feminist cricket lovers, who feel discriminated when only men are allowed to play in Men's Cricket Team.

This movie has weak storyline that defies logic (not that all movies are logical). Actors have overacted. Perhaps the movie leaned too much on cricket to salvage the second half.. Probably making it in a short movie would have worked. Rani Mukherjee did looked like a delicate version of Harbhajan Singh, an Indian cricket player.. At times there were dying sparks of her acting in the movie but those moments were short lived.. The movie failed to have a grip after first 40 minutes or so. It is meant to be a light movie. Yashraj banner has produced good movies like Chandani and Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge. This movie does not reach those standards. A little bit more about the Veer Pratap Singh while playing cricket would have been great. Also, this idea of using cricket or hockey teams in the movie has become slightly stale after the great movies like Chuk de India and Lagaan. Wish this movie lived up to expectations of a movie directed by Aditya CHopra.

I do not know why this movie got only 5.0. I personally liked the movie. Its a good, light-hearted movie with a known theme but a new message in it. Instead of blatant India/ Pakistan match, its about sex and gender. Surprisingly Rani looked good with Shahid (I was skeptical about it at first)..it was really nice to see this unexpected couple. Though this movie is a remake of the movie "She is the Man", I enjoyed myself thoroughly. Anupam Kher, Dilip Tahil, Poonam Dhillon were in cameos, but they did justice to their roles. I have no idea why this movie is rated so less, I really liked this movie. It's short, simple, feel-good family movie, to be enjoyed with a packet of popcorn. I would ask everyone to go and watch this movie. I am sure you will not be disappointed.

I was surprised to how a typical tried out story actually entertained me and made me happy!. Great to see Rani back, her absence was felt and her return is ever so glamorous. Its great to see someone who can really dance match up with Shahid. Shahid is his usual serious self, and doesn't come through much in contact with the viewers, but his acting was tip top and enjoyable. The story was so colorful that i was laughing unexpectedly at times. The make up for Rani as a male was realistic, i actually know someone that looks like that. My only comment is the case of the disappearing and re-appearing eye shadow and make-up. As soon as she throws everything male off she checks in for seconds into invisible beauty salon and re-appears fully beautified :D. More or less very enjoyable and will own it on DVD, the music is lively and makes you want to dance the bhangra. And for you all women rights hater males who voted poor for the movie, let me tell you its not that she was a girl its that she played better than men (in the movie) so the image of weaker sex can't play with guys was abolished and nullified to the zennith.. thats why everyone with a sane mind clapped at the end.