the audience applauded

As somebody who had not heard any of this before, it became a curious phenomenon to sit and watch a film and slowly have the realities begin to click into place.

It is neither dumb nor smart enough to be fun, and spends way too much time with its boring human characters.

One of the film's great tricks is that, for a time, you think it will go down a rabbit hole of unrealistic glorification.

I gave up watching this film in its serial form when it transpired in chapter 4 that Raymond Hatton and Big Boy Williams who were shot dead at the end of chapter 3 were not only miraculously raised to life, but acted as if they hadn't been shot at all and didn't need raising. I decided then and there that I didn't need them either. A wise decision, as this particular fault occurs yet another four times before the serial runs its course. I'm pleased to say that in Grapevine Video's very good cutdown of Republic's 82 minutes version, Hatton and Williams hardly figure in the action at all. In fact, measuring strictly by on-screen time, the stars are Fred Kohler (one of my favorite villains) and Robert Warwick (not one of my favorite actors, but he has some good lines here) with Robert Livingstone making a somewhat immature hero who became rather dashing when doubled by Yakima Canutt – which was at least four or five times, maybe more. Yak also has two or three scenes as one of Kohler's henchmen. William Farnum's somewhat verbose padre has been pared considerably but he still has a great deal of footage in the cutdown, but Williams and Hatton are cut to the bone. I think our lovely heroine, Kay Hughes, has more scenes. Despite the fact that the serial over-ran its budget by just over $5,000, it still cost Republic only $87,655 including editing, titling, scoring and negative costs, but not positive prints and advertising. It was money well spent. By contrast, the studio's most expensive serial was "Captain America" (1943) which cost a whopping $222,906!

This was made in 1936, the very first year of Republic Studios after it was formed from three smaller studios. Probably they were searching for how to do it right, and they hadn't quite hit on it yet--the fights and the cliffhangers are not quite up to Republic's later standards. Several cliffhangers have incredible cheats--they must have counted on the kids not quite remembering exactly what happened the previous week.Speaking of Republic's high serial quality, this serial actually got the soon-to-be-great-director William Witney started in the genre. One of the directors, Mack Wright, was Witney's brother-in-law, who made him an extra, riding in with the Cossacks. He also served as a second-unit assistant director. Two other well-known serial actors have uncredited parts in this: Crash Corrigan ("Undersea Kingdom", "The Painted Stallion") plays Captain Fremont in Chapters One, Eleven and Twelve, and Jack Ingram ("Green Archer", "Jack Armstrong", "White Eagle") plays both a vigilante and a Cossack at various times. At least William Farnum ("Red Ryder", "Undersea Kingdom") did get credited; he plays Father Jose, the Eagle's accomplice. We also get a good look at the all-time greatest stunt man (and director of the Chariot Race in "Ben-Hur"), Yakima Canutt, as an actor--he plays Barsam, the henchman who kills the hero's father and brother in the first chapter and steals the father's ring.Robert Livingston is suitably dashing as the Eagle, sort of a combination of Zorro, the Lone Ranger, and the Durango Kid, with his mask, black cape, white horse, and whip (Livingston also played the Lone Ranger in two subsequent serials). Livingston has not one but two sidekicks, the veteran Raymond Hatton ("Rustlers of Red Dog", "Three Musketeers", "White Eagle") and Guinn "Big Boy" Williams ("Riders of Death Valley"). Kay Hughes ("Dick Tracy") was considered one of the most beautiful of the serial queens, even though she appeared in only two serials (and lots of Westerns). I had never seen Fred Kohler before, but he's effective as Jason Burr, who lusts to become dictator of a new Russian colony in California--and, one presumes, in charge of all time, space, and dimension, like so many deranged serial villains before him.

"The Vigilantes Are Coming" is one of the first, if not the first, serials released by the then newly formed Republic Pictures. It doesn't seem too constrained by budgetary constraints as it boasts the proverbial "cast of thousands".The vigilantes of the title are a group of ranchers led by a Zorro like figure known as "The Eagle". What makes this story different, is the idea of Imperial Russia plotting to colonize early 19th century California and Cossack soldiers ridin' the range. As always, there's plenty of action and the usual heart stopping cliff hangers and last minute escapes.As in most Republic serials, there is a cast of familiar faces. Leading the way is Robert Livingston as the hero whose father and brother are gunned down in the first chapter by Yakima Canutt. This forces Livingston to assume the identity of a mild mannered church organist whose alter ego is "The Eagle". The chief villain, Jason Burr who plots to be the governor "of the new Russian colony" is played by Fred Kohler who graced many a "B" western. The Eagle is given two sidekicks in this one, Guinn (Big Boy)Williams and Raymond Hatton. Heading up the Russian contingent are Robert Warwick as Count Rasminoff and veteran bad guy Robert Kortman as Petroff, the head Cossack. Backing up Kohler are such "B" veterans as John Merton, Bud Osborne and Canutt. Former silent star William Farnum is along as Father Jose head of the mission where the Eagle hides out and Kay Hughes as the typical helpless serial heroine. Ray (Crash) Corrigan, who would team up with Livingston later that year to form two-thirds of "The Three Mesquiteers", appears unbilled as Captain Fremont head of the American brigade.Despite the large cast, there were too few fist fights and too much running around. But as with all Republic serials, the production values were top notch and it was a cut above most other studios output. Beware though that many of the mid-chapter cliffhangers don't match up with "the escape" in the ensuing chapters.